Skip to main content

ESIG - Accelerating the Integration of Variable Generation into Utility Power Systems

  • Members Area
  • About
    • Energy Systems Integration
    • Leadership Team
    • Board of Directors
    • Advisory Council
    • Newsroom
    • ESIG Excellence Awards
  • Blog
  • Resources
    • Resource Library
    • Quick Reference Guides
    • Past Workshop Presentations
    • Past Webinars
    • ESIG Reports/Briefs
    • IEEE Power & Energy Contributions
  • Membership
    • Current ESIG Members
    • Become a Member
    • Member Benefits
    • Student Memberships
    • Mentoring Program
    • Membership Referral
  • Working / Users Groups
    • Task Forces
    • Distributed Energy Resources (DER) Working Group
    • Operations and Maintenance (O&M) Users Group
    • Reliability Working Group
    • Research & Education Working Group
    • System Operation & Market Design Working Group
    • System Planning Working Group
  • Contact
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Sponsorship Opportunities
  • Join
  • Login

Trends of Open-Sourcing Models in the Energy Space

January 6, 2022 by Juha Kiviluoma - VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland

Share this article

Nowadays, many of our most important apps and programs are open source or contain open-source components. In recent years, open-source code has also come into the energy space, where most tools and models had previously been in-house operations (albeit with some notable exceptions). A rather long list of current open-source energy-related models can be found at https://wiki.openmod-initiative.org/wiki/Open_Models. This indicates that open-source development has really broken through, even though there are still many models with research origins inside a walled garden. However, having a large number of separate models is also a challenge. It becomes difficult to identify good models, the effort spent becomes too divided, and many of the models never approach the state-of-the-art frontier.

Juha Kiviluoma

When everybody starts their own models, knowledge doesn’t accumulate as well as it could. Making a good model is much more than writing the equations. There needs to be proper system architecture, data management, interfaces, documentation, tutorials, testing, and verification. The model needs to be very good on at least one, but preferably several, of the common energy and power system modelling aspects: temporal and spatial flexibility, sector-specific representation (e.g., power flows, heat transfers, or small signal stability), computational efficiency, and usability. If the skills of modellers and coders are divided among too many projects, it will not be easy to develop a few good models.

Why So Many Models?

The number of models has been proliferating for several reasons. First, in some quarters, it seems to be almost a requirement for a PhD student to develop their own model. Although it is a good learning exercise, the student could potentially learn more important lessons while contributing to a well-built model. Second, institutions can sometimes discourage participation in shared modelling efforts even if the source code is open—it can be a matter of prestige. Third, it’s really fun to build your own model. Fourth, sometimes it is good to start over. The existing structures in an old model can get too complicated and petrified for continued development, and it can be time to rethink the design. There may also be a more suitable programming or modelling language available.

How to Get over This?

There is a growing recognition that we need a few good models to effectively address the challenges of the energy transition. For example, the European Commission has been funding model development to have alternatives to the closed-source models it has been using to support policymaking. The European Union projects require multiple research organizations to co-operate and contribute to a single effort, like the Spine modelling tools we have been developing over the past four years. There are also efforts to recognize models that are well suited for specific modelling tasks, like LF Energy and Pillar 5, Open Tools and Data, of the Global Power System Transformation Consortium.

Today, there are several high-quality modelling efforts at the different scales of energy and power system modelling. Whether you are a student, manager, engineer, planner, or play any other role in energy systems, please look around and consider whether you or your organization should join an open-source development community to accelerate the energy transition.

 

Juha Kiviluoma
Principal Scientist, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

  • A Transforming Power System
  • Market Evolution in the Western Interconnection
  • National Transmission Policy Actions: Gold Medal for 2021, with Competition from 2022
  • Energy Systems Integration Group (ESIG) Announces 2022 Excellence Awards
  • ESIG Releases Grid-Forming Technology in Energy Systems Integration Report

Filter By Type

Quicklinks

  • Member’s Area
  • Join ESIG

Contact

865-584-0550 x106

PO Box 2787
Reston, Virginia
20195 USA

info@esig.energy

Follow Us!

Follow Us on FacebookFollow Us on TwitterFollow Us on LinkedInFollow Us on YouTube

Special Thanks To Our Sustaining Members

© 2022 ESIG. All Rights Reserved
Custom Site by VIEO Design